Breach of Fiduciary Duty/Trust, Causation, Trustee Discretion

Breach of trust is a type of breach of fiduciary duty. “To prevail on a breach of fiduciary duty, a plaintiff must show: (1) the existence of a fiduciary duty; (2) a breach of that fiduciary duty; (3) causation; and (4) harm.” Matter of Wilma G. James Trust, 487 S.W.3d 37 (Mo. Ct. App. 2016).

For purposes of causation, the usual test is whether the injury or damage is the “natural and probable consequence” of the defendant’s actions. Stanley v. City of Independence, 995 S.W.2d 485, 488 (Mo. 1999). Proximate cause cannot be based on pure speculation and conjecture. Id. Each case is decided on its own facts. Id.

A trustee receives greater protection and deference in breach of fiduciary duty claims where the trustee has sole discretion per the terms of the trust on a matter. In such circumstances, a “court will not interfere in the exercise of that discretion unless the trustee willfully abuses his discretion or acts arbitrarily, fraudulently, dishonestly, or with an improper motive.” Brown v. Brown-Thill, 543 S.W.3d 620, 633 (Mo. Ct. App. 2018).

Related Articles

Will Contests, Self-Proving Wills

March 30, 2023

Will contests are unique for several reasons. Perhaps most significantly, the burden is on the proponent of the document to prove the will was executed and that the testator possessed the requisite capacity. Many times the “proponent” of the will is the defendant in the lawsuit. So, the will contest instructions contemplate the defendant presenting…

Read More

Trustee Abuse of Discretion Factors

October 30, 2022

Increasingly, trust instruments grant trustees “discretion” to do certain acts. Drafters include this language to account for unanticipated circumstances and make a trustee’s life easier. But even where a trustee has discretion, they can act improperly. “A grant of absolute discretion to a trustee is not a roving commission – the trustee must be guided…

Read More

Probate Exception to Federal Jurisdiction

September 9, 2022

There are two main ways for a lawsuit to end up in federal court. First, if the lawsuit “arises under” federal law. This is sometimes called federal question jurisdiction. Second, if there is diversity jurisdiction. There are, in turn, two main requirements for diversity jurisdiction: the amount in controversy must exceed $75,000 and all of…

Read More

Trust Language: “Necessary or Advisable” Distributions

March 4, 2022

The language of a trust is extremely important. And when a will, trust, and other estate documents form part of the same plan, they are interpreted together. Indeed, “[w]hen a trust and will form parts of the same plan, they must be construed together.” Shriners Hospital for Children v. Schaper, 215 S.W.3d 185, 189-90 (Mo….

Read More
Scroll to Top